Quick answer: Visa reason code 13.1 is Merchandise/Services Not Received. The cardholder says they paid for goods or services and never got them. On Shopify it usually appears as Product not received. You win by proving the order was delivered to the address given at checkout, with a carrier scan dated before the dispute and, where you have one, a signature or photo. If you cannot prove delivery because the parcel is lost, returned or still in transit, refunding is usually cheaper than fighting.
Last reviewed 8 October 2026. Card network rules and Shopify's process change, so always check the due date and instructions on your own dispute.
Visa 13.1 at a glance
| Network and code | Visa 13.1, Merchandise/Services Not Received |
| Shopify label | Product not received |
| What the customer claims | "I paid for it and it never arrived." |
| Who it affects | Every store that ships goods or delivers digital products and services |
| Your response window on Shopify | Usually 7 to 21 days, shown on the dispute page |
| Bank decision time | Up to 75 days after you submit, per Shopify |
| How many times you can submit | Once |
| Strongest evidence | Carrier delivery scan to the order address, dated before the dispute; signature or photo; for digital goods, an access log |
| Default call | Fight when delivery is confirmed to the right address. Refund when the parcel is lost, returned or stuck. |
What Visa 13.1 means
Reason code 13.1 sits in Visa's consumer dispute category. The customer's bank has recorded that the customer took part in the purchase but did not receive what they paid for by the date they expected it. That is different from a fraud dispute, where the customer says they never made the purchase at all. See Visa 10.4 for that.
Because the claim is about delivery, the proof is mostly out of your hands: the carrier holds it. That makes timing important. Carriers can take days to give proof of delivery, so start early.
Equivalent codes on other networks
| Network | Code | Name |
|---|---|---|
| Visa | 13.1 | Merchandise/Services Not Received |
| Mastercard | 4853 | Cardholder Dispute (not received is one named condition). See our 4853 guide |
| American Express | C08 | Goods/Services Not Received |
| Discover | RG | Non-Receipt of Goods or Services |
How a 13.1 dispute unfolds on Shopify
Shopify shows the reason in plain words: Product not received. The dispute page shows the amount, the chargeback fee and a due date.
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| Day 0 | The customer's bank raises the dispute. Shopify withdraws the disputed amount and the chargeback fee from your balance straight away. |
| Days 1 to 21 | You gather evidence. Shopify says you usually have 7 to 21 days, and the exact deadline is on the dispute page. |
| Submission | You submit your response, which can be done once. |
| Review | The bank reviews it. Shopify says this can take up to 75 days. |
| Outcome | If you win, the amount is returned, and the fee may be too, depending on your country. If you lose, the money stays with the customer. |
If you use Shopify Payments, Shopify adds order information to your response automatically. What it cannot do is decide whether your delivery proof is strong enough, which is where most disputes are won or lost. See what Shopify submits as evidence.
What the bank actually checks
The bank wants to see that the customer got what they paid for. In practice that comes down to five questions.
- Was it delivered? The carrier's status must say delivered, not in transit or out for delivery.
- Was it delivered to the right place? The delivery address should match the shipping address on the order.
- When was it delivered? The delivery date should be before the dispute was raised.
- Did you ship on time? If you promised delivery within a window, the dates should fit it.
- Is there anything extra? A signature, a delivery photo or a message from the customer acknowledging receipt.
A signature or a delivery photo helps a lot. Without one, the carrier scan and the address match carry the case.
Delivery proof, ranked
| Strength | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Strong | Carrier status "delivered" to the order address with date and time; signature or delivery photo; customer message acknowledging receipt. |
| Medium | Delivered scan with no signature or photo; delivery to a safe place or neighbour recorded by the carrier; proof of access for a digital product. |
| Weak | A tracking number with no delivery status; "out for delivery" only; a scan dated after the dispute; delivery to a different address from the order. |
| None | Lost, returned to sender, or no scans after dispatch. |
Common delivery situations
| Situation | What to do |
|---|---|
| Delivered to the order address, scan dated before the dispute | Fight. This is your strongest position. |
| Delivered but to a different address than the order | Weak. Explain why if you can, but expect to lose. |
| Delivered, but the status is vague or there is no scan detail | Ask the carrier for a proof of delivery before the deadline. |
| Left with a neighbour or in a safe place | Include the carrier's record. A signature is not required for a delivery to count, but it is stronger. |
| In transit or stuck | Wait or refund. You cannot prove delivery that has not happened. |
| Returned to sender | Refund and offer to re-ship. |
| Lost | Refund, and claim from the carrier if you have cover. |
| Parcel locker or pickup point | Include the collection notice or code record. |
| International shipment held in customs | Show the customs status and the date. Delivery has not happened, so refund or wait. |
| Digital product | Fight with an access or download log showing dates and the customer's account. |
| Not shipped at all | Refund. Fix the order and tell the customer. |
Worked example 1: a winnable case
Your store sells candles. An order for £84.50 ships on 8 October with Royal Mail Tracked 48. The tracking shows Delivered on 11 October at 14:12 to the address on the order. On 3 November the customer's bank raises a 13.1 dispute.
- Shopify takes back £84.50 and the chargeback fee (£10 in the UK, per Shopify's help pages).
- You open the dispute, see the due date and send: the order, the tracking number and carrier, the delivery scan with date and time, the delivery address, and a short factual letter.
- If the bank agrees, you get the £84.50 back and possibly the fee.
Your effort was about 30 minutes. If you value your time at £20 an hour, that is £10, against £84.50 recovered. This is worth doing.
Worked example 2: a case to refund
A different store sells a jumper for £62.00. The tracking shows "Delivery attempted, card left" on 14 October, then no more scans. The parcel is returned to the depot and the carrier marks it returned to sender on 28 October. The customer disputes it as 13.1 on 4 November.
There is no delivery to prove. Refund the customer, offer to re-ship if they still want the item, and ask the carrier why the second attempt never happened. A letter would only highlight that the record shows no delivery.
The break-even maths
The disputed amount and the fee are already withdrawn whether you fight or not, so the only extra cost of fighting is your time.
Break-even win chance = value of your time ÷ money you would recover if you win.
| Order value | Time to respond (30 min at £20/hour) | Break-even win chance |
|---|---|---|
| £25 | £10 | 40% |
| £62 | £10 | 16% |
| £84.50 | £10 | 12% |
| £250 | £10 | 4% |
With a delivery scan to the right address, your chance of winning is high, well above these thresholds. Without it, the chance is low and so is the point of fighting. Check your own numbers with our Should I Fight This Chargeback? calculator.
Should you fight it or refund?
| What the tracking shows | What to do |
|---|---|
| Delivered to the order address, before the dispute | Fight. This is your strongest position. |
| Delivered, but to a different address than the order | Weak. Explain why if you can, but expect to lose. |
| Delivered, but no carrier scan or the status is vague | Weak. Try the carrier for a proof of delivery before the deadline. |
| In transit or stuck | Wait or refund. You cannot prove delivery yet. |
| Lost, or returned to sender | Refund, and claim from the carrier if you have cover. |
| Digital product with proof of access | Fight with the download or access log. |
| Not shipped at all | Refund. Fix the order and tell the customer. |
Before refunding an order that already has an open dispute, check with Shopify how the two interact. A refund on top of an open chargeback can mean paying twice.
How to respond to a Visa 13.1 dispute, step by step
- Read the dispute and note the deadline. Open the dispute in Shopify and check the reason, the amount and the due date. Put a reminder a few days earlier.
- Open the order and the fulfilment. Find the tracking number, carrier and shipping address.
- Check the tracking status. Is it delivered? On what date and time, and to which address?
- Ask the carrier for proof of delivery if the scan is thin. Carriers can take days, so do this first.
- Compare the delivery address with the order. Confirm they match.
- Look for customer messages. Any message acknowledging receipt, or asking about delivery, is useful.
- Write a short, factual letter. One page. State what was ordered, when it shipped, when and where it was delivered, using the template below.
- Attach the proof and submit once. Check every attachment opens, and remember you cannot add anything afterwards.
The evidence checklist
Send what you have and leave out what you do not.
| Evidence | Where to find it |
|---|---|
| Order number, date, items and amount | The order page |
| Tracking number and carrier | The fulfilment section |
| Delivery status, date and time, from the carrier | The carrier's tracking page |
| Delivery address, next to the shipping address on the order | The carrier proof of delivery and the order |
| Signature or delivery photo | The carrier's tracking page, if provided |
| Customer messages about delivery | Support inbox or chat |
| Your shipping policy, if it was visible at checkout | Your store policies |
| For digital goods: access or download log with dates | Your app or hosting logs |
A letter you can adapt
To the issuing bank,
We ask that this dispute for order [ORDER NUMBER], [AMOUNT] placed on [DATE], is reversed. The order was delivered to the address given by the customer at checkout.
Order. [ITEMS], shipped on [DATE] with [CARRIER] under tracking number [NUMBER].
Delivery. The carrier recorded delivery on [DATE] at [TIME] to [ADDRESS], which matches the shipping address on the order. [A signature from NAME / a delivery photo] is attached.
Timing. The delivery was made on [DATE], [N] days before this dispute was raised.
Contact from the customer. [We received no message about non-delivery before the dispute. / The customer wrote on DATE confirming receipt.]
The attachments show the order, tracking and delivery confirmation. We ask the bank to reverse the dispute.
Keep the letter short and factual. Do not argue about the customer's honesty.
Common mistakes
- Sending a tracking number without the delivery status. The number alone proves nothing.
- Not checking the address. A delivery to a different address is the most common reason a "delivered" parcel still loses.
- Waiting until the last day. Carriers can take days to give you proof of delivery.
- Writing a long emotional letter. Reviewers read many of these. Short and factual wins.
- Fighting a lost parcel. If you cannot prove delivery, you will pay the fee and lose the sale.
- Ignoring a date mismatch. A delivery scan dated after the dispute does not help.
- Adding documents after submitting. You cannot.
- Missing the deadline. No response means automatic loss.
How to cut down 13.1 disputes
- Send a tracking email at dispatch and one on delivery.
- Use signature or photo confirmation on higher-value orders.
- Check that the shipping address looks right before you dispatch, and ask when it does not.
- Reply quickly when a customer says a parcel has not arrived. Many disputes start as unanswered emails.
- Refund obvious losses early. It costs less than a lost dispute.
- Choose reliable carriers for each destination and track the failure rate by carrier.
- Set honest delivery estimates, and update customers when something slips.
- Use a recognisable billing descriptor so customers can place the charge.
- Watch your overall dispute rate. See chargeback rate and thresholds. For carrier-specific advice see product not received and UK carriers.
Glossary
- Proof of delivery (POD). A carrier record showing a parcel was delivered, often with date, time, location and sometimes a signature or photo.
- Issuer. The bank that issued the customer's card.
- Chargeback. A reversal of a card payment started by the issuer after the customer disputes it.
- Representment. Your response with evidence, sent back to the bank.
- Chargeback fee. A fee charged to you when a chargeback is raised, whatever the outcome. The amount depends on your country.
- Returned to sender. The carrier could not deliver and sent the parcel back to you.
How ChargeFix handles it
ChargeFix reads the tracking number, carrier, delivery status and tracking events from the Shopify fulfilment, and puts the shipping and billing addresses side by side. If delivery is not confirmed, it says so plainly instead of writing a letter that claims it. It drafts the response using only facts found in your records, and you review it before anything is saved or filed. Install it free.
Frequently asked questions
What does Visa 13.1 mean? The cardholder says they did not receive the goods or services they paid for.
Is 13.1 the same as fraud? No. In a 13.1 the customer accepts they placed the order. In a fraud dispute such as Visa 10.4, they say they did not.
What evidence wins a 13.1 dispute? Carrier proof that the parcel was delivered to the address given at checkout, dated before the dispute, with a signature or photo where available. For digital goods, proof that the customer accessed or downloaded the product.
How long does the bank take to decide? Shopify says the review can take up to 75 days after you submit.
How long do I have to respond on Shopify? Shopify says you usually have 7 to 21 days, and the exact date is on the dispute page. Evidence can be submitted only once.
What if the parcel was left with a neighbour or in a safe place? If the carrier recorded delivery to the order address, say so and include the scan and any photo. A signature is not required for a delivery to count, but it is stronger.
Can I fight a 13.1 for a digital product? Yes, with proof the customer accessed or downloaded it, such as an access log with dates.
What if the tracking says delivered but the customer says no? Ask the carrier for a proof of delivery with the address and time. If the address matches the order, fight.
What if the delivery was to a different address? That weakens your case a lot. Explain why if you can, for example the customer asked to redirect, and include that message.
Should I refund before the deadline? If the parcel is lost, returned or stuck, yes. Check with Shopify Support first when a dispute is open, because the customer could be paid twice.
Do I get the chargeback fee back if I win? It depends on your country and payment provider. Check Shopify's help page for your region.
Can I add evidence after submitting? No. Evidence is submitted once.
Sources and review
- Shopify Help Centre, Overview of the chargeback and inquiry process: response window, decision time, fees and accepted evidence.
- Shopify Help Centre, Chargeback reasons: how Shopify groups dispute reasons
- Stripe, Dispute categories and reason codes: the card network code and the category it falls under
- Adyen, Dispute reason codes and defense requirements: what each code covers
- Card network code names are from the networks' published reason code lists, and are consistent across major payment provider guides.
Written by the ChargeFix team. We update this page when Shopify or the card networks change their rules.

01Chargeback guides
02Chargebacks
03Chargebacks
04Disputes
05Reason codes
06Payment methods