You take cards through Shopify Payments, a chunk of orders through PayPal, and now a buy-now-pay-later option. Then a dispute lands. Which system decides, how long do you have, and are you even covered?
Shopify Payments vs PayPal is not a question of which is better, it is a question of different rules. On Shopify Payments the card issuer decides, you usually have 7 to 21 days to respond and the fee is A$25. On PayPal, protection depends on eligibility and proof of shipment, and the rules sit in its Resolution Centre.
This guide is for you if:
- You sell on Shopify in Australia and accept more than one way to pay.
- You have had a PayPal dispute and a card dispute and were not sure why they felt so different.
- You want a simple way to compare payment gateway disputes before you add another payment method.
Last updated: 19 October 2026. Written by the ChargeFix team. Reviewed against sources on 19 October 2026.
The 30-second answer (TL;DR)
- Shopify Payments vs PayPal is a comparison of rule books: each gateway has its own dispute process, deadlines and idea of good evidence.
- On Shopify Payments, a card issuer decides. You usually have 7 to 21 days, the review can take up to 75 days and the fee in Australia is A$25.
- On PayPal, PayPal decides. Seller Protection covers eligible claims if you ship to the address on the Transaction Details page and keep proof of shipment or delivery.
- PayPal Seller Protection excludes item-not-received claims a buyer files directly with their card issuer.
- Wallets and buy-now-pay-later methods have their own windows, often about 180 days, and their own fees.
- Use a one-page scorecard to compare any gateway before you switch it on.
Do this today (10 minutes):
- List every payment method your checkout offers.
- For each, find where disputes arrive: email, Shopify admin or PayPal.
- Put a weekly 10-minute check in your calendar for each place.
A missed notice is the most expensive mistake on any gateway.
From dispute to decision
| Stage | What happens | Your move |
|---|---|---|
| Notice | It arrives in a different place for each gateway | Check every inbox weekly |
| Response window | Shopify Payments usually 7 to 21 days, PayPal differs | Read the due date on the notice |
| Evidence | Each gateway wants slightly different proof | Match the evidence to the gateway |
| Decision | Card issuer, PayPal or the wallet provider decides | Keep records until it closes |
| Aftermath | Fee, payout effect and rate impact differ | Update your scorecard |
Why does Shopify Payments vs PayPal matter for how a dispute plays out?
The gateway decides who judges the dispute, how long you have and what counts as proof. A card payment goes to the cardholder's bank. A PayPal payment goes to PayPal. A buy-now-pay-later payment goes to that provider. Same customer complaint, three different rule books.
That is the heart of Shopify Payments vs PayPal. A card dispute on Shopify Payments is decided by the card company, and Shopify says the review can take up to 75 days after you submit. Stripe, which publishes how disputes work, says that for local payment methods like Klarna and PayPal, the provider decides instead of a card issuer, windows are typically up to 180 days, and fees vary: some charge a single fee only when you lose, others add nothing beyond the standard fee.
So the first thing to learn about any gateway is where the dispute shows up, who is on the other side of it, and what the clock looks like. The rest of this guide gives you a way to do that for each payment method on your checkout.
A quick story (illustration). Hannah sells linen homewares from Adelaide. About 70 percent of her orders are cards through Shopify Payments, 25 percent PayPal and 5 percent buy-now-pay-later. One week she gets a card dispute in her Shopify admin and a PayPal notice in her email, on different clocks. She answers the card dispute and forgets the PayPal one, because it arrived in a different inbox. The PayPal case closes in the buyer's favour. Her fix is dull and effective: one list of every place a dispute can arrive, and one 10-minute check on Monday mornings.
How do Shopify Payments vs PayPal and other gateways compare side by side?
Here is the comparison in one table, using only what the provider pages say. Where a page does not say, the cell says so, because a guess would be worse than a gap.
| Shopify Payments (cards) | PayPal | Stripe direct (cards) | Wallets and buy-now-pay-later | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides | The cardholder's bank | PayPal | The cardholder's bank | The provider, such as Klarna or PayPal |
| Typical response window | Usually 7 to 21 days | Pre-chargeback alert: 20 hours to refund, then the regular ten days; claim windows not verified | 7 to 21 days, depending on the network | Varies by provider |
| Review time after you respond | Up to 75 days | Not verified | Usually 60 to 75 days | Varies |
| Fee in Australia | A$25, returned if you win | Not verified | A$25, plus A$25 if you counter | Varies; some charge only when you lose |
| How evidence is sent | Uploaded in the Shopify admin | Through PayPal's Resolution Centre | Dashboard or API | Provider's own process |
| Seller protection | None; evidence decides | Seller Protection for eligible claims | None; evidence decides | Varies |
| Customer's window to dispute | Typically about 120 days | Not verified | Typically about 120 days | Often about 180 days |
Two patterns stand out in Shopify Payments vs PayPal. First, Shopify Payments and Stripe direct behave alike, because both run on the card networks. Second, PayPal and the wallets run their own processes, so the same complaint can have a different deadline, a different fee and a different standard of proof.
The "not verified" cells matter. I read PayPal's Australian Seller Protection page and its page on pre-chargeback alerts, and neither states chargeback fees, claim response windows or review times. Check your own PayPal account for those, and do not assume they match a card.
How do disputes work on Shopify Payments, and how is that different from PayPal?
A cardholder's bank files the dispute, Shopify takes the amount and the A$25 fee at once, and you upload evidence in the Shopify admin. You usually have 7 to 21 days. The card company then has up to 75 days to decide. Win and you get both back. Lose and both are gone.
Shopify groups card disputes into eight reasons: Fraudulent, Unrecognised, Duplicate, Subscription cancelled, Product not received, Product unacceptable, Credit not processed and General. Each has a list of the evidence Shopify suggests. For example, Fraudulent and Unrecognised point to the fulfilment date and time, billing information, IP address and country, and shipping and tracking. Product not received adds an activity log for digital goods.
Shopify also says that Shopify Payments submits your response on the due date even if you added nothing, that winning does not remove a dispute from your chargeback rate, and that customers are expected to contact you first. Its evidence advice sorts proof by strength, from direct records like signed delivery or refunds, to customer acknowledgement, to policy documents, to context such as order records and verification results. Label each piece, and use screenshots instead of links.
In Shopify Payments vs PayPal terms, the strengths of this model are structure and clarity. You know the clock, you know the fee and you know the evidence list. The weakness is that nothing protects you automatically. If the evidence is thin, you lose.
How do disputes and PayPal Seller Protection work in Shopify Payments vs PayPal terms?
PayPal handles claims through its Resolution Centre and offers Seller Protection on eligible transactions. The Australian Seller Protection page says it covers item-not-received claims filed through the Resolution Centre and unauthorised payment claims where the transaction is marked eligible, if you meet its conditions.
For physical items, the conditions on PayPal's Australian page include shipping to the address on the Transaction Details page, responding to documentation requests within the required time, and providing valid proof of shipment or delivery. For intangible goods, the page says you must meet integration requirements, provide evidence the item was delivered as described or the service completed, and have paid the transaction fees on the sale.
The page also lists exclusions that matter in Shopify Payments vs PayPal planning: real estate, businesses, vehicles, claims marked Significantly Not As Described, item-not-received claims a buyer files directly with their card issuer, items prohibited by PayPal's Acceptable Use Policy, industrial machinery, and cash equivalents such as gift cards. It says coverage is for the total purchase amount on eligible transactions. It does not state a response timeframe, caps or chargeback fees.
PayPal's page on pre-chargeback alerts adds a clock. It says you get a 20-hour window to refund transactions without fulfilled orders, which avoids applicable fees. Outside that window you get the regular ten days to respond, and you may be unable to avoid the chargeback or its fee. For fulfilled orders you can submit evidence in the alert, and PayPal uses it to contest the chargeback if one arrives. The alert shows in the Resolution Centre as a High Priority case.
Illustration 1: the address rule. A customer pays A$280 through PayPal. The Transaction Details page shows a delivery address in Perth. The customer emails a different address in Fremantle, and you ship there with tracking. Later the buyer files an item-not-received claim through the Resolution Centre.
| Shipped to | Proof | Likely position |
|---|---|---|
| The Transaction Details address, with tracking | Tracking and delivery proof | Within Seller Protection conditions, if the transaction is eligible |
| A different address, with tracking | Proof of shipment, wrong address | Outside the stated shipping condition |
| The Transaction Details address, no tracking | No valid proof | Outside the proof condition |
The difference between the first and second row is up to A$280 plus the goods. Because the rules say to ship to the Transaction Details address, any change of address needs to go back through PayPal. This is the biggest practical difference in Shopify Payments vs PayPal. I could not verify how PayPal treats an address change requested by the buyer, so check with PayPal before you ship anywhere else.
What happens with wallets and buy-now-pay-later disputes?
Each provider has its own rules, and the Shopify Payments vs PayPal gap is smaller than the gap to a wallet. Stripe says that for local payment methods, the provider decides, buyers typically get up to 180 days, fees vary, and some include an inquiry phase where you can resolve the issue before a formal dispute. Read the dispute page of each method before you switch it on.
Stripe's categories page shows how provider codes map onto its eight categories, which is a handy way to see what customers actually claim. Here are the PayPal and Klarna reasons it lists.
| Provider | Reason as the provider words it | Closest category |
|---|---|---|
| PayPal | Unauthorized | Fraudulent |
| PayPal | Merchandise or service not received | Product not received |
| PayPal | Merchandise or service not as described | Product unacceptable |
| PayPal | Duplicate transaction, payment by other means | Duplicate |
| PayPal | Credit not processed | Credit not processed |
| PayPal | Canceled recurring billing | Subscription cancelled |
| PayPal | Incorrect amount | Unrecognised |
| PayPal | Other, problem with remittance | General |
| Klarna | Unauthorized purchase | Fraudulent |
| Klarna | Goods not received | Product not received |
| Klarna | Faulty goods | Product unacceptable |
| Klarna | Already paid | Duplicate |
| Klarna | Return | Credit not processed |
| Klarna | Incorrect invoice, high risk order | General |
This mapping is Stripe's, not PayPal's or Klarna's, so it is a guide to Shopify Payments vs PayPal complaints and not a rule, and it shows that the customer complaints are familiar. Not received, not as described, unauthorised, duplicate and refund claims appear everywhere. What changes is the process: where you answer, how long you have and what the provider treats as proof.
For a deeper view of one reason, such as the general bucket, see the guide on how to respond to a general dispute. The evidence principles carry across.
How do you compare payment gateway disputes before you add a new method?
Use a scorecard, and do the Shopify Payments vs PayPal comparison on paper first. Before you switch on a new gateway, answer eight questions from its own pages. The score is not the point. The point is knowing, before the first dispute, where it arrives, how long you have and what it costs.
GATEWAY DISPUTE SCORECARD
Gateway: [name] Date checked: [date]
1. Where do dispute notices arrive? [email / admin / dashboard / app]
2. Who decides? [card issuer / provider / other]
3. How long do I have to respond? [days; from where]
4. What is the fee in Australia? [amount; returned on a win?]
5. Is there a second fee if I respond? [amount]
6. How long can the customer wait to file? [days]
7. Is there seller protection? [yes / no; conditions]
8. What proof does it want? [tracking / signature / logs / other]
Notes
Exclusions I must watch: [ ]
Anything I could not find: [ ]
Who checks this inbox on Mondays: [name]
Fill one sheet per gateway and keep them together. When a provider changes its rules, update the sheet. That small habit turns a payment gateway disputes mess into a single reference.
| Question | Why it matters | Where to find the answer |
|---|---|---|
| Where do notices arrive? | A missed notice almost always loses | Provider help pages, your account settings |
| Who decides? | Sets the standard of proof | Provider dispute pages |
| Response window | Sets your plan | The notice itself |
| Fee and refund on a win | Sets your break-even | Provider fee page |
| Customer window | Sets how long to keep records | Provider dispute pages |
| Seller protection conditions | Can change how you ship | Seller protection page |
What is the short answer on Shopify Payments vs PayPal for a busy owner?
If you only have five minutes, here is the whole of Shopify Payments vs PayPal in plain terms. Shopify Payments gives you a structured card dispute with a reason, a due date and an evidence form inside your admin. PayPal gives you a separate inbox, the Resolution Centre, and protection that depends on eligibility, shipping to the right address and answering quickly.
So the real work in Shopify Payments vs PayPal is not picking a winner. It is keeping two sets of habits. For cards, build the file early and submit before the due date. For PayPal, check eligibility and the address before you ship. Write both on one page and pin it where your team works.
The same page should list who watches each inbox. Most missed deadlines in payment gateway disputes happen because nobody owns the second inbox. Name one person, give them a weekly check, and the Shopify Payments vs PayPal gap stops costing you money.
How does Shopify Payments vs PayPal change your payouts and cash?
On Shopify Payments, the rules are documented. Payouts have a minimum settlement time of 2 business days in Australia, chargebacks can settle faster than charges and reduce a payout, a negative balance delays payouts until future sales cover it, and reserves can hold part of your sales. On PayPal, I could not verify how a dispute affects your balance.
That gap is worth closing before you grow. Open your PayPal account and find out what happens to the money when a case is opened: is it held, is it deducted, and for how long? Write the answer on your gateway scorecard. The guide on chargeback cash flow explains why timing matters as much as the amount.
A simple rule works across both: treat disputed money as gone until the case is closed, and keep a buffer in the bank account that Shopify debits. If you run a lean account, one dispute in each system in the same week is the scenario to plan for.
What does a missed notice really cost?
In Shopify Payments vs PayPal, a missed notice is the most expensive mistake on either side.
Pay Advantage says missing the deadline almost always means an automatic loss. With several gateways, the risk of missing a notice goes up because there are more places to look. Even a modest miss rate costs more than a weekly check.
Illustration 2: one inbox versus three. Suppose you get two disputes a month across your payment methods, each for A$300 plus the A$25 fee. Assume that with no routine, one notice in ten is missed, and a missed notice is a lost dispute.
| Option | Working | Cost per month |
|---|---|---|
| No routine | 2 x 10% x (A$300 + A$25) | A$65 expected loss |
| Weekly 10-minute check | 4.3 checks x 10 minutes = 43 minutes at A$40 an hour | About A$29 of time |
On these assumptions, the routine saves about A$36 a month, or A$432 a year, before counting the stress. The numbers are made up to show the shape: when the amounts are larger or the miss rate higher, the routine matters more. It also makes the fee tables irrelevant if you simply do not answer.
How do you ship PayPal orders so Seller Protection still applies?
Follow the same short routine on every PayPal order: check the address on the Transaction Details page, ship to that address, use a service that gives delivery proof, and save the proof. Seller Protection is conditional, so the routine is the product.
PAYPAL ORDER CHECKLIST
[ ] Transaction is marked eligible on the Transaction Details page
[ ] Shipping address in my system matches the Transaction Details address
[ ] Any address change request sent back through PayPal, not agreed by email
[ ] Shipped with tracking that shows delivery
[ ] Delivery proof saved as a screenshot
[ ] Digital goods: download or activity log saved
[ ] Documentation requests answered inside the time shown
[ ] Case notes saved with the date
PayPal's page lists the proof of shipment or delivery condition, and says to respond to documentation requests within the required timeframe, though it does not state that timeframe. When in doubt, answer the same day. This checklist takes about two minutes per order and protects the full purchase amount on eligible transactions.
What should you do when disputes from two gateways land in the same week?
This is where Shopify Payments vs PayPal stops being theory and becomes a calendar problem.
When Shopify Payments vs PayPal disputes arrive together, triage by clock, not by size. Look for the shortest window first, which is often a PayPal pre-chargeback alert with a 20-hour refund option, then the card dispute with a 7 to 21 day window. Decide, collect evidence once and reuse it.
Here is a day-by-day plan. A PayPal pre-chargeback alert appears on Monday 7 December 2026 for an order you have not fulfilled, and a Shopify Payments card dispute lands on Tuesday 8 December 2026 with a due date of Tuesday 22 December 2026. Your own dates will be on the notices.
| Date | Task | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Mon 7 Dec | Open the PayPal alert. For an unfulfilled order, decide on a refund inside the 20-hour window. | Decision on the alert |
| Tue 8 Dec | Log the card dispute with its due date. Check your balance. | Both clocks on one sheet |
| Wed 9 Dec | Export order, payment and delivery records for both. | Shared exhibits saved |
| Thu 10 Dec | PayPal: collect proof of shipment or delivery. Card: build the file by reason. | Gateway-specific files started |
| Fri 11 Dec | Contact both customers, kindly. | Messages sent and saved |
| Mon 14 Dec | Draft cover notes. | Draft v1 |
| Tue 15 Dec | Read cold. Fill gaps. | File v2 |
| Thu 17 Dec | Submit the card response and update PayPal, days before the due date. | Confirmations saved |
Shopify Payments sends your response on the due date even if you added nothing. Finish before the date, and check what each provider shows as submitted.
What do you keep in a shared evidence folder?
The same folder serves both sides of Shopify Payments vs PayPal, so you only build the habit once.
One folder per order holds everything either gateway could ask for. Name files by date and type, so you can build a response for any provider in minutes. The structure below works for cards, PayPal and wallets.
EVIDENCE FOLDER (one per order)
01_order_record order page, line items, totals, discount codes
02_payment_record payment checks, gateway name, last four digits
03_confirmation_email order confirmation as sent
04_shipping_email dispatch email with tracking number
05_tracking screenshots of each scan, final delivery scan
06_customer_messages full thread, including your messages
07_policies returns and shipping policy as shown at purchase
08_listing product page, photos, description at purchase
09_refunds any refund or replacement, with dates
10_notes what you decided and when
For PayPal, make sure item 05 shows proof of shipment or delivery to the address on the Transaction Details page. For digital goods, replace 05 with the download history or activity log. Keep records for 12 to 18 months, as Pay Advantage suggests.
Which wins on disputes, Shopify Payments or PayPal, for your store?
There is no universal winner in Shopify Payments vs PayPal. Shopify Payments gives structure and a clear clock. PayPal gives Seller Protection when you meet its conditions, but the conditions are strict. Wallets bring longer windows. The best setup is the one you can monitor, evidence and afford, and Shopify Payments vs PayPal is only part of that choice.
| If you... | Lean toward | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Ship physical goods with tracking | Cards and PayPal, with Seller Protection conditions met | Address changes, untracked parcels |
| Sell digital goods | Cards, with logs ready | PayPal's integration requirement for intangible goods |
| Sell high-value items | Cards with 3D Secure where available | Pay Advantage advises 3D Secure for higher-risk orders |
| Sell overseas | Cards plus local wallets customers trust | Longer windows and extra fees |
| Have one person doing support | Fewer methods, so Shopify Payments vs PayPal is a real choice | Missed notices |
If you are weighing Shopify Payments vs PayPal as an extra method, count its dispute inbox as a cost. A method that brings 10 percent more orders but a separate dispute process, a separate clock and a longer customer window may not be worth it for a small team. A method that replaces untracked bank transfers with a structured process may be. The same test applies when you compare Shopify Payments against PayPal.
What is different for Australian merchants?
General information, not legal advice.
Fees and process
In Shopify Payments vs PayPal terms, the chargeback fee on Shopify Payments in Australia is A$25, returned if you win. The response window is usually 7 to 21 days and the card company's review can take up to 75 days after you submit. Stripe lists A$25 for a dispute received and A$25 more if you counter, on its own accounts, for disputes initiated after 17 June 2025.
PayPal in Australia
For Shopify Payments vs PayPal, PayPal's Australian Seller Protection page lists the conditions and exclusions above. It does not state fees, caps or a response timeframe, and its pre-chargeback alerts page gives the 20-hour refund window and the regular ten days but no amounts. Check your own PayPal account and its Australian fee page before you finish your Shopify Payments vs PayPal comparison.
Banks and rules
Pay Advantage says chargebacks in Australia are governed by the ePayments Code, administered by ASIC, and apply to most Australian banks and to Visa, Mastercard and American Express. It advises tailoring evidence to the reason, sending PDFs, keeping records for 12 to 18 months and using 3D Secure for higher-risk orders. It also notes that missing a deadline almost always means an automatic loss.
Time limits
State consumer bodies say chargeback time limits commonly run from 45 to 120 days depending on the card provider, and the ACCC notes that time limits may apply when you sell online. I carried the range from earlier research and could not re-open the Consumer Affairs Victoria page.
What I could not verify: PayPal's chargeback fees and response windows for Australia, how PayPal handles an address change from the buyer, how other gateways such as local wallets compare, and a published win rate for any gateway.
What are the common mistakes when comparing Shopify Payments vs PayPal?
Most of these come from treating Shopify Payments vs PayPal as one rule book, when it is two.
- Assuming PayPal works like Shopify Payments, when Shopify Payments vs PayPal rules differ.
- Missing a notice because it arrived in a different inbox.
- Shipping to a different address than PayPal's Transaction Details page shows.
- Skipping tracking on PayPal orders.
- Expecting PayPal Seller Protection to cover an item-not-received claim filed directly with a card issuer.
- Not reading the dispute page before switching on a wallet or buy-now-pay-later method.
- Using the same evidence for every provider, when each wants slightly different proof.
- Waiting for the due date, when Shopify Payments sends whatever is on file.
- Forgetting that a won card dispute still counts toward the chargeback rate.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference in Shopify Payments vs PayPal disputes?
On Shopify Payments, a card issuer decides, you usually have 7 to 21 days and the fee in Australia is A$25. On PayPal, PayPal decides, and Seller Protection covers eligible claims if you meet its conditions, such as shipping to the Transaction Details address and keeping proof of shipment or delivery.
In Shopify Payments vs PayPal, which protects me from chargebacks?
PayPal's Australian page says Seller Protection helps guard against claims, chargebacks and reversals on eligible transactions, but it excludes item-not-received claims a buyer files directly with their card issuer. Conditions apply, including shipping to the address on the Transaction Details page and valid proof of shipment or delivery.
How long do I have to respond to a PayPal dispute?
PayPal's pre-chargeback alert page says you get a 20-hour window to refund unfulfilled orders, then the regular ten days to respond. I could not verify the response window for claims in the Resolution Centre, so check the deadline shown on your own case.
What does a Shopify Payments dispute cost in Australia?
Shopify says the chargeback fee in Australia is A$25, withdrawn with the amount when the chargeback is filed and returned if you win. Stripe lists a separate countered fee for its own accounts. I could not verify whether Shopify Payments adds one, so check your fee page.
Which proof do I need on PayPal?
For physical items, PayPal's Australian page says valid delivery proof, shipped to the Transaction Details address, and timely replies to documentation requests. For intangible goods it asks for evidence the item was delivered as described or the service completed, plus meeting its integration requirements.
Do buy-now-pay-later disputes follow card rules?
No. Stripe says local payment methods like Klarna and PayPal have their own processes, with the provider deciding, windows often about 180 days and fees that vary. Some include an inquiry phase. Read each provider's dispute page before you switch the method on.
Is Shopify Payments or PayPal better for digital products?
You can, but read the conditions. PayPal's Australian page says intangible goods need integration requirements met, evidence the item was delivered or the service completed, and the transaction fees paid. Keep download logs or activity records ready, as you would for a card dispute.
How do I stop missing dispute notices on several gateways?
List every place a dispute can arrive, then check each one weekly. A ten-minute Monday check costs far less than a lost dispute, and Pay Advantage notes that missing a deadline almost always means an automatic loss. Put the list and the checker's name on one sheet.
Can I use the same evidence for every gateway?
Mostly, but tailor it. Pay Advantage advises matching evidence to the dispute reason. Keep one shared folder per order, then pick the pieces each gateway wants, such as tracking for PayPal or the activity log for digital goods on cards.
Does a won PayPal or card dispute help my chargeback rate?
On Shopify Payments, no. Shopify says the rate is based on disputes filed, not outcomes. I could not verify how PayPal measures it. Either way, the cheapest outcome is a dispute that never arrives, which clear descriptors, tracking and fast replies help to prevent.
Start free trial with ChargeFix
ChargeFix gathers the real order, payment-check and delivery records for a Shopify dispute and drafts the response, using only real data and never inventing facts. In Manual mode you review and send each filing yourself, and Auto mode files the cases your rules allow, so whichever side of Shopify Payments vs PayPal your next dispute lands on, the card file goes out early and finished. Start free trial
Sources
- Reasons for a chargeback or inquiry, Shopify Help Center
- Overview of the chargeback and inquiry process, Shopify Help Center
- Preventing chargebacks and inquiries, Shopify Help Center
- PayPal Seller Protection, PayPal Australia
- Resolve disputes, PayPal Australia
- Dispute reason code categories, Stripe Docs
- How disputes work, Stripe Docs
- Understanding chargebacks, Pay Advantage
- Selling online, ACCC
01Chargeback costs
02Chargeback costs
03Dispute reasons
04Preventing disputes
05Fight or accept
06Australian Consumer Law and refunds